Red-and-Meth
American League MVP?
I say Papi. I hate to regurgitate something I heard, but it was a very cogent point, so I will say it here, forgetting who deserves credit for it. Papi is MVP, Gayrod is player of the year.
A-Rod is a freakin pimp...especially when the yankees are up by 10 runs. I have no way of verifying this but I feel pretty certain that the number of big, clutch hits he has had in a yankee's uniform would fit on one hand.
Papi on the other hand has 20 homers this year that have either tied the game or put the sox up! That's just unprecedented - there's no precedent, baby! That doesnt even mention other clutch hits he has had, nor his catalytic presence in the clubhouse (I mean, he has no other duties but to chew on things, pump up his boys, and go hit the ball)
So, give it to the crazy dominican...or whatever he is
Lemme know your thoughts...and really, if you have another topic, throw it at me - I'm bored
--BD
Two things. 1) I could just save myself and everyone else a lot of time and just go with the Plumley perspective and argue that the AL shouldn't even get an MVP since they don't actually play "baseball", since the pitcher doesn't have to hit. But we all know that's just crazy talk. 2) My argument won't even resemble an objective one because I can't stand the red sox beating the Yankees. It's so unnatural, not unlike David Blaine making a deal with the devil.
In the spirit of not being objective and slurping the Yankees, unapologetically, I'm just gonna come out and say it; A-Rod (that's Alex Rodriguez's nickname) should win the MVP and Player of the Year. Yeah...
Not to sound like Plumley, but I don't think it would sit right with me if a DH (or a Red Sox player) got the MVP. I think it’s a perfectly acceptable form of baseball (having the DH) but playing that position almost forfeits your chances at the MVP. Barry Bonds (post Balco, post gold glove days) is suddenly coming to mind... I think Big Papi is pretty valuable, but only on offense. He brings absolutely nothing to the team defensively. He is clutch like Derek Jeter. No question. His efforts are always timely. But I feel like A-Rod is your more valuable player, because he is helping the team from all angles. The guy is as strong a hitter as Papi (though maybe not as clutch) and they're talking Gold Glove for him, defensively. And he can steal bases better than Ortiz could steal your TV.
P.S. Every time I start thinking about sports awards, I'm always reminded of that guy on MTV's Dismissed. The guy that said he wasn't just a playa, he considered himself an All-Star.
--Shifta'
I love that you mentioned the "all-star" b/c i try to work that comment/joke into conversation at least once a month...
Before i go into this, let me ask you - when plumley makes the bigs, do you think he would rather play "real baseball" and strikeout looking or on a failed bunt OR be in the AL and get a chance to rest his achy old-man frame between innings?
OK - now we're talkin. I would actually be more open to the idea of Jetes getting MVP over Papi (and therefore A-rod, obviously) - That guy's got more intangibles than Hubie Brown can shake a stick at...and unlike A-rod, he can actually hit a ball in a close game, rather than watching strike 3 and then making a whiny face before smiling his way back to the dugout (b/c he knows he's getting amazing pussy after a game, win or lose...right?)
As for Papi and DH, look at the name of the award "most valuable" - that doesnt mean best in baseball, or even best on one's own team. That means you take their attitude, performance, intangibles, (unintentionally) comedic interviews, and all of that into account. I think Papi deserves it...
And i dont know why you gotta bring up the past - Papi's theft charge (the TV) was dismissed, much like my "statutorily awesome" charge
Brucey D.
I was with you all the way on that one, man. 13? She looked 30! I saw her...
I love the all-star joke. It's one of the great 'unoriginals' that we’re (in)famous for.
I hate to speculate about which league Plumley would prefer. I guess time will tell on that one.
If there was a MEP (most entertaining player) award, who would the finalists be? Manny immediately comes to mind? But who else could even compete? Is he the list? I can't even think about Manny without "My Immortal" (at all times playing in my head) stopping for a moment and then circus music starting up. That guy is so spectacular. Cinema has Will Ferrel, and biesbol has Manny Ramirez.
I'm pretty sure the entire thing is trivial and irrelevant (like our lives), because everyone knows that the MVP is going to the minority player on the penant winning team. That's what it's come down to.
Btw, this post is approaching a Bill Simmons-like size. But that's whatchoo gotta do when you find yourself in the middle of a vicious cock fight!
Wow, it really did get out of hand there, didn't it?
Just a few quick notes, and i'll lay this baby to pasture...
Which version is playing in your head - the rocked-out version, or the original?
Ever since Piazza stopped dying his hair, i cant think of another MEP, unless you count giambi's, bonds', and palmeiro's laughable denials of taking steroids...hmm
rickey henderson isnt still giving interviews in the 3rd person is he?
maybe i just dont watch enough biesbol, but i know theres gotta be a couple somewhat mainstream jokers out there [im thinking pitchers or outfielders] that we're missing...i'm in a glass case of emotion over it, honestly
in any event, its time to drink
This just came to me - a guy by the name of Jose Canseco - maybe you've heard of him? He's kind of a big deal around here...
If he still played, I would say he had what it took to be a competitor. But even then -- bouncing a pop fly off of your head doesn't really put you at the same level as burning down a blunt inside the green monster during a game. What could, really?